Tag: Interpretation

Jones v. Harris Associates L.P. and the Limits of Public Choice Textualism

Daniel Birk

The pronouncement “A book is the words that comprise it” risks seeming an insipid axiom.  Nevertheless, we are all inclined to believe that there is a form separable from the content and that ten minutes of conversation with Henry James would reveal to us the “true” plot of The Turn… Read More »

The Limits of Advocacy

Amanda Frost - America University Washington College of Law

Party control over case presentation is regularly cited as a defining characteristic of the American adversarial system. Accordingly, American judges are strongly discouraged from engaging in so-called “issue creation”—that is, raising legal claims and arguments that have been overlooked or ignored by the parties—on the ground that doing so is… Read More »

Modernization, Moderation, and Political Minorities: A Response to Professor Strauss

Jonathan F. Mitchell - George Mason University School of Law

The Supreme Court is frequently accused of declaring laws unconstitutional based on little more than the justices’ ideological preferences. This is an especially common criticism of the Court’s capital-punishment, equal-protection, and substantive-due-process jurisprudence, where the justices have made little effort to tie their decisions to anything resembling a neutral principle.
In… Read More »

The Modernizing Mission of Judicial Review

David A. Strauss - The University of Chicago Law School

Constitutional interpretation looks to the past: to an old text, to old precedents, to the views of the founding generations, to tradition. That is the conventional wisdom, at least. Judicial review, as it’s usually conceived, is a matter of using principles rooted in these sources to limit current popular majorities.… Read More »

Choosing Interpretive Methods: A Positive Theory of Judges and Everyone Else

Alexander Volokh - Emory Law School

Textualism is a “conservative” method of statutory interpretation, according to the conventional wisdom.  For example, Bradford Mank rejects the suggestion that textualism can be friendly to environmental regulation, noting that “textualists tend to devalue the policy balances struck by environmental agencies… Read More »

links:1 ugg bailey button hogan outlet gucci outlet borse gucci moncler 2013 scarpe hogan piumini moncler louis vuitton outlet moncler outlet ugg boots on sale louis vuitton italia borse louis vuitton discount uggs cheap nike free runs nike air max womens moncler outlet deutschland cheap authentic nfl jerseys northface uk nike free run womens nike uk store gucci homme nike deutschland kinder uggs doudoune moncler pas cher air max donna scarpe hogan uomo jordan femme pas cher cheap air max jordan basket basket nike pas cher aire max pas cher nike elite trainers air max 90 femme ugg greece nike free run 2 nike running sito ufficiale louis vuitton sac louis vuitton pas cher uggs sale nederland discount nfl jerseys nfl replica jerseys nike blazer femme nike golf shoes longchamp pas cher michael kors deutschland chaussures air jordan nike free pink moncler sale moncler jackets nike shox rivalry pas cher nike free run australia